Contact Butch

L.S. “Butch” Mazzuca
Columnist, Photographer

7590 E Rudasill Rd
Tucson, AZ 85750

Direct: 303-882-5588
bmazz68@icloud.com

Headlines before Facts

by | Dec 4, 2025 | Recent Commentaries

People believe what they want to believe—especially regarding politics because political views become tied to tribe, self-image, and emotion; so, accepting contradictory evidence feels like a threat.  To avoid that discomfort, we gravitate toward information that confirms what we already think while dismissing anything that challenges it.

After years of headlines, leaks, and breathless speculation, the Russia-collusion story boiled down to being a politically funded opposition-research dossier full of unverified claims that were used by a compromised FBI and major media as evidence that Donald Trump conspired with Moscow.

Mueller, DOJ IG, and later Durham found not one scintilla of conspiratorial evidence.  Key allegations were traced back to dubious sources, political operatives, and circular reporting.  In the end, the real scandal wasn’t Trump’s collusion with Russia—it was how intel agencies and the press ran with a narrative that was 100% politically motivated fiction.

During the peak of the Russian collusion hysteria, the legacy media treated the rumors, hearsay, and wishful thinking as if it were a CIA briefing.  Today, the Washington Post (an outlet that won a Pulitzer for the Russian collusion story) now runs with a jaw-dropping war-crime accusation before anyone knows whether it’s fact, fiction, or a bad game of telephone.  Both the collusion hoax and the drug boat story use the same formula – “If it’s sensational and politically explosive, print first, confirm later.”

Both then and now endless stories built on “people familiar with the matter,” have turned out to be not very familiar with the matter.  Sources say the Secretary of Defense ordered the second strike to kill survivors clinging to their sinking boat.  A logical question would be, how many sources and how solid are those sources?   But it doesn’t matter – a headline in an age when anonymous sourcing becomes a weapon is all the Left really wants.

The Russia-collusion narrative shaped politics, investigations, hearings, and public opinion long before anyone asked, “Is any of this real?”  In Hegseth’s case, a war-crime accusation instantly frames him as a monster—before facts, context, or verification even enter the room.  In both cases the accusation becomes the truth as democrats pile on.

Arizona Senator Mark Kelly joined a video with several other Democratic lawmakers warning U.S. service members that if they receive orders that are illegal, they have a duty to refuse them.   The senator is a former Navy captain and knows better.  But he defended the video under the principle that U.S. troops are bound not just by orders, but by law and the Constitution.  Yet when questioned, neither Kelly nor any of his democrat cohorts could offer evidence of any illegal orders, so why was the video necessary?

After the Washington Post reported that Hegseth ordered a follow-up strike that killed survivors of a prior boat attack on a suspected drug-trafficking vessel, Kelly publicly condemned what he called potentially illegal or immoral orders — and demanded accountability.  Ah yes, demand accountability for the potential of something happening.

Kelly is doing something the democrats have crafted into an art form when they want an anti-Trump headline sans evidence.  He’s demanding accountability for something that might have happened, could have happened, or sounds like it happened — but hasn’t been verified as actually happening.  That’s not accountability, that’s pre-emptive political outrage.  And the truly sad aspect of the matter is that millions of Americans, especially those afflicted by TDS will wallow in the story as if it came from the burning bush.

I don’t know what occurred during that strike, but I do know that if the claim collapses the story will be buried on page 20.  We’ve seen this before, a major news outlet tosses a political grenade that instantly ripples into hearings, outrage, and investigations before any facts are known.  And like the Russian collusion hoax, the political “ecosystem” creates reality, not the evidence.

Quote of the day: “A lie can travel halfway around the world before the truth can get its pants on.” – Mark Twain