Contact Butch

L.S. “Butch” Mazzuca
Columnist, Photographer

7590 E Rudasill Rd
Tucson, AZ 85750

Direct: 303-882-5588
bmazz68@icloud.com

The Constitution Isn’t a Restaurant Menu

by | Nov 16, 2026 | Recent Commentaries

Would you hire your neighborhood handyman to perform heart surgery on your child? Of course not. Yet many supposed intelligent Americans have just elected people to Congress who advocate sweeping changes to our system of government who don’t have even the most rudimentary understanding of the U.S. Constitution.

The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) and their ideological allies are a fascinating group. They have ambitious plans for the United States, and I don’t mean relatively simple undertakings like balancing the federal budget, reforming Social Security, or reducing the national debt. Those challenges seem modest compared with what the DSA has in mind.

According to its National Program, released in July 2026, the DSA wants to abolish the United States Senate, eliminate the Electoral College, replace the presidency, and subordinate the judiciary to Congress.

In other words, the DSA wants to fundamentally reconstruct the constitutional framework of the United States, replacing our system of three coequal branches of government with one in which Congress exercises ultimate authority over the executive and judiciary.  Interestingly, that arrangement bears a striking structural resemblance to China’s National People’s Congress, where the executive and judiciary are subordinate to the legislature.  So much for the separation of powers our Founding Fathers considered essential to preserving liberty.

Our Founders created a bicameral legislature for a reason.  The House represents the people according to population, while the Senate gives every state equal representation, regardless of size.  The DSA would eliminate that arrangement.

But saying something and doing something are two very different things, and the biggest obstacle they’ll encounter is Article V of the Constitution.

Article V specifically protects each state’s equal representation in the Senate, providing that no state can be deprived of that representation without its consent.  Consequently, abolishing the Senate isn’t simply a matter of convincing Congress to vote itself out of existence.  It would confront one of the Constitution’s most formidable protections.  Good luck with that.

Then there’s the presidency.

Article II establishes the office of president and vests executive power in that office.  The DSA proposes replacing the president with an executive chosen by and subordinate to Congress.  But that’s not all.  It also wants the judiciary similarly subordinated.

Think about that for a moment.  Our Constitution separates legislative, executive, and judicial authority.  The idea was straightforward: Concentrating too much power in one branch of government invites precisely the abuses our system of checks and balances was designed to prevent.

I’m sure I’ll step on some toes here, but I believe we’re seeing the consequences of a public education system that has failed to teach basic civics and American history.  An understanding of those subjects might remind Americans why democracy without meaningful checks on political power can become a mobocracy.  Imagine two wolves and a lamb voting on what to serve for dinner!

But there’s also a practical problem.

Amending the Constitution ordinarily requires a two-thirds vote in both houses of Congress, followed by ratification by three-fourths of the states.  Alternatively, applications from 34 state legislatures can trigger a convention to propose amendments, but ratification by 38 states would still be required.

And considering Congress’s chronic inability to even agree on and pass a budget, does anyone seriously believe it could assemble the extraordinary national consensus necessary to abolish the presidency, eliminate the Senate, and fundamentally restructure the Supreme Court?

The irony is that, through the constitutional amendment process, the DSA would first need a two-thirds vote from the very institution it wants to abolish.  Why not ask the board of directors of the Ford Motor Company to vote itself out of existence?

There’s nothing inherently illegitimate about proposing constitutional amendments.  The Founders provided a mechanism for changing the Constitution precisely because they understood that future generations might see things differently.

But they deliberately made that process difficult.  Fundamental changes to our government were supposed to require something more substantial than a temporary political majority or an aggressive ideological movement.

And that’s what makes the DSA’s ambitions so alarming.  This isn’t a disagreement about tax rates, healthcare, or government spending.  It’s a proposal to replace the constitutional framework that has governed the United States since 1789.

The Constitution isn’t a restaurant menu from which political movements can simply cross off the institutions they dislike.  And that’s the most reassuring part of this entire discussion.

There is, however, one important distinction.  Unlike abolishing the Senate or presidency, expanding the Supreme Court does not require a constitutional amendment.  Congress can change the number of justices through ordinary legislation. Consequently, any future congressional majority with sufficient political support could  reshape the Court without overcoming Article V’s formidable barriers.

The good news is that dreaming doesn’t amend the Constitution. The troubling part is that  Americans have elected representatives sympathetic to these sweeping changes, giving their advocates a greater voice in the very government they propose to reconstruct.  As the old saying goes, once the camel gets its nose under the tent, the rest may not be far behind.